All three of these fryers are built to handle whole turkeys, and they are really fast at what they do. But which one of the three is best and why?
With turkey season fast approaching, we all want to get our hands on a turkey fryer that is not just capable, but that will deliver the best results. The Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer, Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer, and Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryers are all built to handle whole turkey. So, what sets them apart?
What are the differences between the three?
Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer vs. Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer vs. Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryer – How do they compare?
Fryer capacity
The Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer is a massive appliance that allows you to fry up to 25 pounds of turkey. With the Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer, you get a maximum frying capacity of 16 pounds, and the Butterball Masterbuilt XL Fryer allows up to 20 pounds of turkey.
Seeing as it provides the highest capacity, the Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer wins in this category.
Frying mode
With the Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer and the Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryer, you have to use oil to get your turkey and other foods cooked. The Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer, in comparison, takes advantage of infra-red heat to fry your meats.
The Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer wins this category as it incorporates healthier cooking methods and saves you money while at it.
Energy source
To get your oil hot and turkey frying, the Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer and Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryer depend on electricity while the Char-Broil Oil-Less Turkey Fryer depends on propane to run.
Since electricity makes an economical frying method, the Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer and Butter Ball Masterbuilt XL Fryer tie to win this category.
Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer vs. Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer vs. Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryer – Comparison Overview
Bayou Classic Turkey Fryer
This electric oil fryer is large enough to handle a commercial setting with its 25-pound capacity. It is made of aluminum which makes it easy to clean. It comes with a patented poultry rack and lift hook.
Pros
- Very large
- Great for commercial use
- Patented rack and hook
Cons
- Requires lots of oil
Char-Broil Oil-Less Turkey Fryer
- CAPACITY: Fry whole turkeys, chicken, or roasts up to 16 pounds
- COOKING TECHNOLOGY: TRU‑Infrared cooking technology for even heat and no flare-ups
- RELIABLE: Rotary ignition for quick and easy starts with the turn of a knob
This fryer uses infra-red to fry turkeys and other meats, and it offers a maximum capacity of 16 pounds which is pretty decent. It runs on propane and is easily portable.
Pros
- Can be used where there is no electricity
- Reduces oil used
- Easy to use
Cons
- A bit expensive
Butterball Masterbuilt XL Electric Fryer
- CAPACITY: Fry whole turkeys, chicken, or roasts up to 16 pounds
- COOKING TECHNOLOGY: TRU‑Infrared cooking technology for even heat and no flare-ups
- RELIABLE: Rotary ignition for quick and easy starts with the turn of a knob
This electric fryer is great for home and commercial settings since it works fast. It is made from stainless steel which is easy to clean, and it offers many safety features.
Pros
- Fast
- Easy to clean
- Safe
Cons
- Expensive
Verdict: So, which is best?
Since it strikes a balance between cost, versatility, and safety, the Char-Broil Oil-less Turkey Fryer makes the best of the three fryers.