Growing herbs may not be the most complicated gardening task, but finding the right soil might turn into a joyless ride.
As a gardening enthusiast, I've never had problems with my outdoor planters and raised flower beds. However, it was a whole new ballgame when I decided to grow a herb garden in the kitchen.
While the idea was pretty neat, buying the right potting mix needed a ton of research and groundwork. Nevertheless, I ended with some of the top products available right now.
Hi! I'm Stacy Smith, and today I'll be talking about 5 best potting soil for herbs. And by the end of this guide, I'm confident you'll find the most suitable option.
So, let's get started.
Top 5 Potting Soil For Herbs Reviews
1. Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix
The Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix is an excellent option for users looking to keep their herbs healthy and growing. This product is formulated to ensure maximum nutrient supply, and as such, caters to a wide range of potted plants.
Product Highlights
First things first, this is one of the most versatile blends with a balanced composition enabling optimal plant growth from the get-go. As gardening enthusiasts, we often worry about buying the wrong pot mix, which could potentially grow fungus.
However, you need not worry about this one, as it does not contain compost or bark, which are known agents for sheltering fungus gnats. Other than that, it includes coconut coir, allowing absorption and release of water for easy re-wetting.
This bit is essential if you want the potted plants to be self-providing, with minimal grooming needs. So, if you're looking for something that will make plant care low-maintenance and hassle-free, get this right away.
Besides, it can feed for up to 6 months, which practically saves your time, effort, and money. All you need to do is pick a container with a drain hole and fill 1/3rd of it with the potting mix.
What's There To Like About It?
Well, as a retired individual, I prefer using plant products that streamline grooming and care. And frankly, this Miracle-Gro item is a life-saver in that respect, as it pretty much takes care of everything.
What impressed me the most is its self-wetting formula, which absorbs and releases water to provide the necessary hydration. However, some potted plants have specific watering needs, so you might want to check that before using this variety.
What's There Not To Like About It?
You must be wondering what could be wrong with this product, especially when I couldn't stop raving about it a while back. Well, I have no complaints about its composition or performance, but I would have liked it better if the bag came with a zip lock or seal.
I usually keep my pot mixtures in the outdoor shed or basement, but without a locking mechanism, it could potentially become an insect hub.
Pros and Cons of Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix
Pros
Cons
- Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix feeds houseplants for up to 6 months and is designed to be less prone to gnats (contains no compost or bark, which are known to shelter fungus gnats)
- This potting mix contains coconut coir, which holds and releases water and helps soil re-wet
- Blended potting soil for a wide variety of indoor container plants, including climbing, foliage, flowering, and tropical plants
2. Organic Potting Mix by Perfect Plants
Plants that grow in containers need special care and nourishing soil that enhances their overall nutrient and immunity level. That's why I recommend the Organic Potting Mix by Perfect Plants for the healthy growth you desire.
Product Highlights
First of all, unlike the previous product, this all-natural blend is formulated for both indoor and outdoor use. This is a significant advantage considering some of us want to hang or display our planters outside.
Furthermore, it ensures adequate water management, so your plants get the required hydration in all situations. It's suitable for a wide variety of vegetation, including fruits, vegetables, small trees as well as annual bloomers.
That said, it comprises three main components - Perfect Plants Perlite, peat moss, and coconut coir. All of these ingredients are added to supply the necessary nutrients and moisture, ensuring conducive growth conditions.
However, that's not all; it also contains worm castings, mycorrhizae, and composted pine bark combined with lime for the ideal pH balance. Lastly, it's available in a resealable bag, ensuring maximum protection against the elements and insect intrusions.
What's There To Like About It?
There's hardly anything not to like about this product, but what impressed me the most is its composition. For instance, the mycorrhizae fungus enhances root establishment while also increasing nutrition level without requiring artificial fertilizers.
Other than that, the worm castings serve as additional protection for the plant roots, preventing damage from extreme soil conditions. Therefore, if you're aiming for vibrant and rich foliage, this soil mix will not disappoint. I also like that it comes in a resealable bag, ensuring convenient storage throughout.
What's There Not To Like About It?
For most parts, I'm satisfied with the performance of this potting mix; however, it's quite expensive for an 8-quart bag, and that could be a deal-breaker for some. So, if you have more than a few pots, this may not be the best option since you'll be running out of mixture soon enough.
Pros and Cons of Organic Potting Mix by Perfect Plants
Pros
Cons
- 🌱 ALL NATURAL MIX Suitable For Use On Edible Plants like FRUITS & VEGETABLES
- 🍎 MYCORRHIZAE ENRICHMENT — Aids Root Growth as well as increased Nutrient Absorption for your Plants
- 💧EASY-TO-MANAGE DRAINAGE — Blended with Perfect Plants Perlite
3. The Next Gardener Seed Starting Potting Mix
No products found.
Up next, I've picked the Next Gardener Seed Starting Potting Mix, another excellent option for users looking to expand and diversify their green space. So, whether you want to grow herbs, flowers, or vegetables, this product is designed to deliver.
Product Highlights
To begin with, I'm very impressed with the professional-grade formulation of the potting mix, ensuring optimal growth and nourishment. To explain further, it contains the highest quality blonde sphagnum peat with traces of frost gold and some organic fertilizer to speed up root development.
This makes it the perfect choice for indoor ornamental seedlings and cuttings planted in paper plugs or trays. Furthermore, it's suitable for organic herbs, fruits, vegetables, flowers, succulents, etc. So, if you're looking for a truly versatile pack for multi-use, this mix will not disappoint.
Other than that, it's lightweight, airy, and pH balanced, which are all significant advantages for indoor vegetation. Since it's 100% organic, you need not worry about the impact of artificial chemicals. Lastly, it comes in a reusable sealed bag, allowing easy storage and access during use.
What's There To Like About It?
To be honest, I cannot get enough of its wide applicability, as any gardening enthusiast will know how difficult it is to find a product like that. As such, I use it for my kitchen herbs and raised bed garden flowers that demand nutrient-rich soil.
Composition-wise, it's easily one of the best options, maintaining a 5.5 pH level to ensure the required acidic balance. I also like how airy and lightweight the mixture is, providing enough nourishment without choking the roots.
What's There Not To Like About It?
There's very little to not like about this product, given that it is one of the best potting soil for herbs. However, the only thing that bugs me is the inconsistency in its texture. Long story short, the soil tends to get a bit lumpy, and you'll have to break up the mounds before applying. Nevertheless, this is a minor inconvenience and doesn't affect overall performance.
Pros and Cons of The Next Gardener Seed Starting Potting Mix
Pros
Cons
No products found.
4. Burpee Premium Organic Potting Mix
The Burpee Premium Organic Potting Mix is another ready-to-use option that provides all the nurturing your herbs need. As a gardening enthusiast, I understand the need for soil that's self-sufficient, catering to all of the plants' requirements. This one checks that box and more.
Product Highlights
First things first, this product is supplemented with Burpee plant food, ensuring higher nutrition uptake in plants. Therefore, if you're looking for something that works with herbs as well as flowering plants and vegetables, this one perfectly fits the bill.
Other than that, it's suitable for both container and raised bed gardening, ensuring maximum convenience throughout. But that's not all; the mix is formulated in such a way that it instantly feeds the plants and then gradually provides plant food for up to 3 months.
This makes it more sensitive to the plants' needs, ensuring adequate nutrition in different stages of growth. Other than that, it contains coconut coir, which maintains moisture in-between the watering sessions, thus yielding lavish foliage and vigorous blooms.
So, if you like to keep plants low-maintenance and well-nourished, this mix will work out fine. Lastly, it's OMRI-listed and hence is completely organic, which is what most gardening experts recommend for herbs.
What's There To Like About It?
There are many reasons, but the most important one is its composition. For starters, it's enriched with Burpee plant food, providing high nutrition and nourishment that aids plant growth. It even includes coconut coir, which is an organic and sustainable substance, ensuring adequate moisture levels at all times.
With my herbs, I often worry about over or under-watering, so I like it better when the mix takes care of the hydration. Hence, this is a perfect option to keep things well balanced.
What's There Not To Like About It?
Well, there's no point sugarcoating this, but this soil mix is slow in producing results. Therefore, if you want a fast starter, this product may not live up to your expectations. In that case, I'd suggest looking for alternatives, as this potting mix has a lengthier cycle than most other organic options.
Pros and Cons of Burpee Premium Organic Potting Mix
Pros
Cons
- ALL-NATURAL MIX: Burpee Organic Premium Potting Mix is formulated with plant food & coconut coir to promote seed & root growth and healthy flower, vegetable & herb plants. OMRI Listed for organic use.
- PERFECT FOR CONTAINERS: Use this growing mix for planting in containers or raised beds. The potting soil feeds plants instantly, then provides a slow-release plant food that feeds for up to 3 months.
- RETAINS MOISTURE: Sustainable coconut coir helps hold the right amount of water for potted plants, indoors or outdoors. Coconut coir is an organic and sustainable resource that helps maintain moisture between waterings.
5. Rio Hamza Trading Soil Mixture
No products found.
Now that I've reached the end of my compilation, I'd like to finish off with the Rio Hamza Trading Soil Mixture. If you're worried that your herbs will dry out prematurely, get this to ensure higher sustenance and better growth.
Product Highlights
First off, this all-natural pot mix formulation is specially designed for indoor herb gardens, delivering high yield and more flavor. As such, it works for both planters and pots, so you may use whichever is convenient. So, whether you're growing herbs in small pots on the kitchen window or in a planter, this 4-quart bag should suffice.
Furthermore, it includes different enriching substances like peat, worm castings, lime, and perlite, ensuring a steady supply of nutrients throughout. The combination also encourages fast and new growth, which is what most of us want anyway.
Other than that, it's pretty easy to use and does the job without requiring much effort on your part. Honestly, that's what makes it one of the most user-friendly options, which is especially an advantage for gardening novices. So, if that sounds like a good deal, get this right away.
What's There To Like About It?
There's no doubt that herbs are easier to grow than flowers, fruits, or vegetables. However, the right soil mixture can make things more convenient, and hence this Rio Hamza Trading product is one of my top choices.
When I started with my kitchen herb garden, this product streamlined things and ensured fast growth in a matter of days. Besides, it contains all the necessary nutrient-rich substances like peat, worm castings, perlite, etc., making it all the more viable.
What's There Not To Like About It?
This is one crucial bit of information you should consider before buying this product. Basically, the soil tends to attract houseflies and other common insects, so you might want to keep an eye out to prevent an infestation. That said, I would have liked it better if the soil was sterile as nobody wants their house or kitchen buzzing with flies.
Pros and Cons of Rio Hamza Trading Soil Mixture
Pros
Cons
No products found.
Buyers Guide
Knowing all about the 5 best potting soil for herbs may seem enough information to go ahead and buy one. However, you still need to figure out what works best for your plant buddies.
That's why I have put together a brief buyer's guide to walk you through some key considerations. Let's take a look now.
1. Composition
This may seem like a no brainer, but the composition of the potting mix is one of the critical aspects guiding purchase decisions. By now, you already know that the formulation may vary from product to product, but it's essential to find the suitable one for your herbs.
The ideal composition further depends on factors like temperature, location of plants, etc. That said, some plants contain peat, perlite, and worm castings, while others include mycorrhizae and lime. The idea is to get a mix with balanced nutrients, so your plants can get adequate quantities of each.
2. Coconut Coir
Ideally, I'd suggest looking for products that contain coconut coir, as it enables improved water management in the potting soil. This is an efficient organic substance that ensures that your herbs are getting the right amount of hydration at all times. This bit is crucial as you don't want your plants to dry and wilt prematurely.
Coconut coir essentially releases water between the watering sessions to prevent drought-like conditions. Besides, it makes things exceedingly low-maintenance by taking care of your herbs, even if you skip a few watering sessions.
3. Wide Applicability
This may not be a top criterion; however, wide applicability is a significant advantage you cannot ignore. While you could always get a product suitable for herbs only, it's more cost-effective to buy one that works for flowers, fruits, and vegetables as well.
That said, some products on my list are suitable for a wide variety of vegetation, including garden flowers, indoor cuttings, and ornamentals, succulents, etc. But then again, don't assume or experiment with the soil - make sure to verify the application range before buying.
4. Indoor/Outdoor Use
The next point you should weigh-in on is whether the soil is meant for only indoor use or works everywhere. This point is an extension of the previous one, as wide applicability also implies that you can use the product in indoor and outdoor gardens.
In case you need a potting mix solely for a kitchen herb garden, an indoor variety will suffice. However, I strongly suggest not to apply an indoor mix to raised beds or pots outside, as it can develop mold or attract insects, eventually killing the plants.
5. Soil Sterility
Any soil naturally contains pathogens and bacteria that can potentially harm or kill plants. Therefore, it's important to sterilize it before planting any vegetation. Potting soils are usually available in the sterilized form, but you should verify that while buying. After all, you don't want your herbs to die due to overlooking this crucial information.
6. pH Balance
This is another essential factor you cannot overlook. The soil's pH level is usually mentioned in the product description, so it's best to find something with the right value. Also, some products contain lime, which ensures perfect pH balance.
7. Organic
Not all potting soils are completely organic; some may contain traces of chemical fertilizers and other artificial components. If you want something truly organic, check for the OMRI or relevant labels on the product. Do not solely rely on the manufacturer's claim, as it could be a case of misleading or false advertisement.
8. Resealable Bags
I'd recommend buying potting soils available in resealable bags, as it ensures better storage and accessibility. Besides, when it's properly sealed, it enables protection against insects and elements. This may not be a top priority, but it'll come in handy in the long run.
Frequently Asked Questions
It'd be unwise to assume that all potting products are suitable for growing herbs. The soil requirements for herbs are not entirely the same as any other vegetation. So, you might want to get something specifically intended for the purpose, to ensure maximum growth and flavor.
Ideally, no, but then again, a lot depends on the product’s composition. For instance, products containing coconut coir are more water-efficient, providing adequate hydration at all times. So, you might want to read the instructions as there's no set standard for all products. Besides, it may also depend on the existing temperature and environmental conditions in your area.
My Final Recommendation
That’s all from me!
I hope you could find the most suitable option from my top 5 recommendations. However, before you get all excited about placing an order, here’s some advice.
Make sure to get a soil mix that’s self-sufficient and can do the job with minimal oversight. After all, you’d want your herbs to grow on their own, without needing a lot of supervision. On that note, I’d like to take your leave with a quick recap of my findings.
The Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix is the best overall, and the Organic Potting Mix by Perfect Plants is the most versatile option.
Till next time! Stay herby!